I think _Ares_ makes the best point in favor of AW so far (the whole perverse incentives idea) and that should be good enough reason for admins to give AW in this case.
About Buga's point(s), I don't agree that %ages don't matter - For example, in a 1v1 if one player kills one of the enemy vils with his scout at min 10 and game freezes (or even simpler, one guys loses vil to boar because of lag and not poor skill :P), then given that there is a CLEAR advantage to the other at this point, should we give AW?
No, right? because the odds are not past 75-25, they're maybe 60-40(?) and so 50-50 is closer than 100-0
About Buga's point(s), I don't agree that %ages don't matter - For example, in a 1v1 if one player kills one of the enemy vils with his scout at min 10 and game freezes (or even simpler, one guys loses vil to boar because of lag and not poor skill :P), then given that there is a CLEAR advantage to the other at this point, should we give AW?
No, right? because the odds are not past 75-25, they're maybe 60-40(?) and so 50-50 is closer than 100-0