Girino imo. There were always some great Brazilian players, but he was above the rest for a period of time. Back then, out of the guys in the poll I think only Alive was a top player, but he didn't seem as good in 1v1 as in TG's.
Alive is probably second best.
Third would be between dog and riut.
I never rated Logan, Hammet, Gunnah, GP, Matador, etc (though he was one of my favourite 1v1 players) too highly compared to the others. All very good players, but none of them were at the top level in 1v1. Maybe tg's, but I don't care about that.