Recorded Game Analyzer Guidelines
1. Purpose
Recorded Game Analyzer (RGA) should provide the reader with a qualitatively good and in-depth analysis about the game and point out good moves and suggest some improvement.
2. Analysis
Each comment should have 3 parts, rating of the game, highlights of the game and the actual analysis of the game (, but it is acceptable to do only one or two of the three parts).
Only expert games will have rating and highlights of the game. Recorded Games of beginners who wants to learn how to improve will not be rated.
Rating of the Game
The rating scale is from 0 - 10.
0 - the game was not played or lasted under 5 minutes (such games will not analyzed anyway)
1 - a game that lasted under 10 minutes without any battles or highlights
2 - a game that lasted under 15 minutes without any battles
3 - a bad game with one player or team dominating the game
4 - a bad game with only one major battle
5 - an average game with less battles
6 - an average game with some battles
7 - a good game with long lasted battles
8 - a good game with some highlights or with long lasted battles
9 - a must-watch game with some highlights and equal teams
10 - a must-watch game with many highlights and very equal teams
These should only give an advice what the rating means for RGA and the reader. Therefore it is possible that some RGA has totally different opinions about the rating. Also in the first post should contain the final average rating.
Note also that even a game that lasted only 10 minutes could get a high rating if there is something new or innovative.
Highlights of the Game
This part should be in a spoiler in order to not ruin the fun for the readers.
Highlights of the Game show what kind of game it was and why it is worth watching. Also this should provide the reader with the option to search for one kind of game such as a game with a come-back.
RGA is free to use any highlights, but in the near future the highlights will be collected and unified to remove the possibility of misunderstanding.
Analysis of the game
This should be in a spoiler in order to not ruin the fun for the readers.
This part should give a qualitativly good and in-depth analysis of the game. RGA should also give the reasons why a strategy/tactic/move was good/bad in the given situation.
Also it is RGA’s decision how deep he wants to analyze, but RGA should complete his analysis until the end.
EXAMPLE
Rating: 9.5
Highlights:
3. Participation (if you are not RGA, this would be interesting to you)
Communication
Please keep this section clean. For now, comments from non RGAs is allowed, but please do not flame or post random comments. The primary goal is to keep this section short and informative. Therefore it is good if all comments are directly related to the given game and not commenting to other members posts.
Do not offend RGAs. Is not only the rule of AoCZone to keep a good environment, but I will prohibit any offense to RGAs.
Posting Games
If you are a beginner and want that your recorded game is anlyzed by RGAs, please upload your recorded game in the recorded games section and post a link here. Please do not open a topic by yourself.
For times being, the limit of the recorded games on the beginners wish list is 3 games per player.
If you want that RGAs analyze an expert recorded game, please upload the recorded game in the right recorded games section and post a link here. If you an expert player you can post your own games too. Also if a RGA wishes to analyze a game please do the same thing. Please do not open a topic by yourself.
Analyzing
RGA will choose a record game from the wish list and start a topic about this game. Then other RGA and non RGA can post their analysis of the game.
Guideline
If you think some part of this guide line is poorly written or incorrect (in grammar, spelling or way of thinking) then please post your improvement here. I will considere to change this guideline.
1. Purpose
Recorded Game Analyzer (RGA) should provide the reader with a qualitatively good and in-depth analysis about the game and point out good moves and suggest some improvement.
2. Analysis
Each comment should have 3 parts, rating of the game, highlights of the game and the actual analysis of the game (, but it is acceptable to do only one or two of the three parts).
Only expert games will have rating and highlights of the game. Recorded Games of beginners who wants to learn how to improve will not be rated.
Rating of the Game
The rating scale is from 0 - 10.
0 - the game was not played or lasted under 5 minutes (such games will not analyzed anyway)
1 - a game that lasted under 10 minutes without any battles or highlights
2 - a game that lasted under 15 minutes without any battles
3 - a bad game with one player or team dominating the game
4 - a bad game with only one major battle
5 - an average game with less battles
6 - an average game with some battles
7 - a good game with long lasted battles
8 - a good game with some highlights or with long lasted battles
9 - a must-watch game with some highlights and equal teams
10 - a must-watch game with many highlights and very equal teams
These should only give an advice what the rating means for RGA and the reader. Therefore it is possible that some RGA has totally different opinions about the rating. Also in the first post should contain the final average rating.
Note also that even a game that lasted only 10 minutes could get a high rating if there is something new or innovative.
Highlights of the Game
This part should be in a spoiler in order to not ruin the fun for the readers.
Highlights of the Game show what kind of game it was and why it is worth watching. Also this should provide the reader with the option to search for one kind of game such as a game with a come-back.
RGA is free to use any highlights, but in the near future the highlights will be collected and unified to remove the possibility of misunderstanding.
Analysis of the game
This should be in a spoiler in order to not ruin the fun for the readers.
This part should give a qualitativly good and in-depth analysis of the game. RGA should also give the reasons why a strategy/tactic/move was good/bad in the given situation.
Also it is RGA’s decision how deep he wants to analyze, but RGA should complete his analysis until the end.
EXAMPLE
Rating: 9.5
Highlights:
come-back, double boar stealing
Bla Bla Bla Bla Bla
3. Participation (if you are not RGA, this would be interesting to you)
Communication
Please keep this section clean. For now, comments from non RGAs is allowed, but please do not flame or post random comments. The primary goal is to keep this section short and informative. Therefore it is good if all comments are directly related to the given game and not commenting to other members posts.
Do not offend RGAs. Is not only the rule of AoCZone to keep a good environment, but I will prohibit any offense to RGAs.
Posting Games
If you are a beginner and want that your recorded game is anlyzed by RGAs, please upload your recorded game in the recorded games section and post a link here. Please do not open a topic by yourself.
For times being, the limit of the recorded games on the beginners wish list is 3 games per player.
If you want that RGAs analyze an expert recorded game, please upload the recorded game in the right recorded games section and post a link here. If you an expert player you can post your own games too. Also if a RGA wishes to analyze a game please do the same thing. Please do not open a topic by yourself.
Analyzing
RGA will choose a record game from the wish list and start a topic about this game. Then other RGA and non RGA can post their analysis of the game.
Guideline
If you think some part of this guide line is poorly written or incorrect (in grammar, spelling or way of thinking) then please post your improvement here. I will considere to change this guideline.