Hi, I had posted this as a reply in the below thread:
viewtopic.php?f=1079&t=135526#p544164
Being posted as a reply, it could miss the attention of the admins, so creating a separate thread.
It is not my intention to create any disturbances in the proceedings. I will agree with whatever decision you make. Thank you for organizing everything
viewtopic.php?f=1079&t=135526#p544164
Being posted as a reply, it could miss the attention of the admins, so creating a separate thread.
Hi, can someone please check the group 3 table and confirm if the ranking is wrong.
I can't find the rules for ties. However it seems logical that winner in the match between the tied players should get the higher rank. Also I won against both my opponents (won both sets) while the rank 1 player has won only against one opponent (won one set, lost one set).
Seems like an error to me :D
EDIT: ok, I found this.
This should be valid only if all three players have the same score (so each has a win and it is not possible to establish who performed better).Group Ranks: If players have equal points at the end of Group Stage, the final positions will be randomly set.
But if only two players have same score, it is very easy to establish who performed better. Moreover, it seems unfair that one player can get higher ranking by winning against only 1 opponent (and losing against second player) while second player won against both.
I request the admins to reconsider the rankings.
It is also mentioned in the rules that admins can make addition or modification of rules during the tournament if needed, so I hope this can be done. Moreover, the rules seem to suggest that random ranking is done only if all three players have same score (so that best performer can't be determined).
In any case, thank you for the efforts
It is not my intention to create any disturbances in the proceedings. I will agree with whatever decision you make. Thank you for organizing everything