I think the biggest issue for civs like Saracens is how they buffed the spearmen line vs camels to compensate for imperial camels. That nerf to the Indians indirectly really nerfed the Saracens and the Berbers as well (but the Berbers have a lot of other options).
I think the bonus damage for the spearmen line should be reduced and the unit and upgrade costs for mamelukes should be reduced.
I think the bonus damage for the spearmen line should be reduced and the unit and upgrade costs for mamelukes should be reduced.