The rule shouldn't be all TC up there is no way to tell this apart from complex score analysis. What i meant is if anyone has tc they can kill vills by garrisoning and it should be ok. This is how regular non-tourney nomad is playedThis was the case before, but how do the players know when tc's are up?Why time bind this at all? I honestly had no idea there is a time limit rule in tournies for this doesnt matter when it was introduced. Why cant the rule be, No vill fights till tc is up. In other words if you have TC its ok to kill enemy vills with it but no vill fights.
I understand the point of the rule but there is no way to enforce this unless its a treaty(AOE HD) like setting. Maybe a mod can be made to enforce this, not sure(gallas help :twisted: )Also this rule is to prevent the scenario where your vill is still on the way to your own tc (which might be up already), but your vill is walking under the enemy tc by accident.
Come what may there is an element of luck in aoc and more so in Nomad/no tc maps no amount of rules can change this.It can happen and it will set you behind quite far if you lose the vill, while there's nothing you could do about it and it's not something that's skill-based, it's entirely luck-based, so I think the rule is fine.