A
Guest
If i allow her to play, how do i explain to others beeing a bit higher than 1650 that they are not allowed? You think they care if she is more known than others? they act in their own interest and i cant give them a point why there is a difference between them. according to the rules i cant defend my decision.
You could say (for instance) that she didn't reach >1650 rating by playing herself, and that someone else has played for her. (I think there is no question about this, it's a fact). And that player X can play provided that X can prove that someone else played for X to reach that rating. Now, giving a convincing proof for something like this tends to be hard, and for that reason it wouldn't even be worth to read such requests.