i have readed the rulez and i dont like xD.
First game Arg play with 3 players normaly and win.
Arg B 1- RDK 0
Second game, Arg play with same 3 players and win but broke a rule. AL for Arg or rematch the game, admin decide.
Arg B 1 - RDK 0/ Arg B 1 - RDK 1
It is very diferent of RDK 1 - Arg B 0 .
Admins re check the decition admins plz.
I rechecked the rules and it seems they haven't changed since I last time read it. And the rules are reasonable in my opinion.
Of course it is reasonable, its written there to punish clans who do not follow rules they agreed to, not to favour them by just making them replay the 2nd game only. The 1st game is part of the match series vs RDK. For examploe: If you use a smurf in the 2nd game what u think will happen with all the games? AL...but you only used a smurf in the 2nd game right? The first was fine, so why get an AL in the first? Punishment...follow the rules and you'll have no problem.
Of course it is reasonable, its written there to punish clans who do not follow rules they agreed to, not to favour them by just making them replay the 2nd game only. The 1st game is part of the match series vs RDK. For examploe: If you use a smurf in the 2nd game what u think will happen with all the games? AL...but you only used a smurf in the 2nd game right? The first was fine, so why get an AL in the first? Punishment...follow the rules and you'll have no problem.
Of course, if somebody smurf or cheat must be punish with Admin loss in all games, but that is totally diferent case. We didn't cheat or smuft, we just forgot the rule that we have to use another player, ok we deserve loss the 2nd game, but the 1st one?
A mistake, is not the same that cheating, and that is a thing that you should know at the time of make the rules. And is more obvious in our case, Arg have more than 50 members in aoc section, we have 3 teams (A,B,C) playing several leagues at the same time, we don't make this for cheating, was only and mistake, and we are getting punished like we are smurfed.
This is not reasonable, don't matter how u try to justify.
Is ok, arg will play the games anyway, i know that there is no way back, but don't try to make us belive that is a reasonable rule.