Thats why I kind of like the bottom 4 are relegated/top 4 promoted while next top4/bottom 4 fight for the spots. I agree there is something special about fighting for those slots, but its a very hard sell to me to say that 1/3 of the league should be replaced each season with players who have not had to beat anyone in the top 24 to get promoted over them. Plus this way you get an extra, super high takes and marketable event.Having promotion based on qualifiers against those potentially getting relegated seems unnecessary. I like seeing players get relegated/promoted outright, means there's something meaningful to play to achieve/avoid each season and makes it a little more cut-throat. Whether the number being promoted and relegated is right might be up for debate, but the principle is solid.